Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>There's a video where a Monsanto lobbyist spouts circular talking-points about how glyphosate was safe to drink, offered either Round Up or glyphosate and refused to drink it.

But, you can actually watch a video of someone else drinking some! (at about 8:00) : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M8sgEhpHM4k



Here's a comment on the video by the user K SA:

> The bar tender reaches down at 5:16 and brings up a different glass than the one he pours the chemicals in so this is a snow job. The two glasses have a different shape too and the new glass is greener. This is so fake. Why do the guys sprying this crap wear spacesuits if it is so safe?


> Why do the guys sprying this crap wear spacesuits if it is so safe?

The guy on the street outside wears thick waterproof pants and thick waterproof rubber boots when he cleans the street with a pressurized water hose.

Water is generally considered safe [citation needed], but you still don't want to get hosed in it for hours on a daily basis.

- Constantly wet feet catch fungus and foot rot.

- Water lowers your body temperature, making you more susceptible to infection from and outbreak of common cold.

- Containing water contamination to an surface - instead of your clothes and skin - makes it easier to rid yourself of surplus water when taking a break.

- Wet clothes are highly impractical because they are heavy and shed water everywhere you go for hours after.

TLDR; Protective clothing doesn't imply toxicity.


Same reason the doctor leaves the room when you take an X-ray. The issue isn’t one time exposure it’s repeated exposure.

The issue with roundup isn’t whether it’s safe if you drink it (most “safe” cleaners, etc will at least make you feel crappy if you just drink them - he’ll copper sulphate spray used for low level onset protection would send you straight to hospital if you drank it).

It’s a matter of cumulative exposure and time. Most cancers, even chemically induced ones take time to become large enough to be noticed and people get many different cancers naturally - if a small amount of roundup cause cancer immediately it would be gone already.

Much like Uber I take issue with the unethical behaviour of Monsanto in multiple areas. Maybe roundup is safe and could be used as icing at a five year olds birthday, but they shouldn’t be ghost writing papers for journals.

Also unethical is allowing someone to ghostwrite a paper for you and publishing it with your name.


> Why do the guys sprying this crap wear spacesuits if it is so safe

They are protecting against a lifetime of large exposures.


> They are protecting against a lifetime of large exposures

Would eating food products everyday be considered a "lifetime of large exposures"?


LOL. That's actually stupid or actually fake. :)




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: