Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Someone I studied with made a keyboard that changed the size of keys based on the probability that they are used next.

It was unusable. Because of the constant size changes you would hit the wrong keys and some were getting so small you couldn't hit them anymore.



anecdata: smartphone keyboards do this invisibly, no visual change but the most probable next keys get larger input geometry so that even if you don't hit it right, it will register.


I'd love to be able to see statistics about hits and misses on this, because in more than 10 years of touchscreen smartphone usage, I'm still yet to type even a single sentence correctly. I hold out hope for a decent dialling wand.


Look into the MessagEase keyboard. It's IMO about the optimum available phone keyboard input. With a little practice you can touch-type naturally, though it's never going to be as fast as a full size keyboard of course.

Really the only downside is having to put a bit of effort into learning it, but for the amount of time I personally spend typing on the phone over the years, it's well worth it.

I also tried other keyboard formats. 8pen was kind of interesting, but I could never get it very consistent myself, it felt more like a gimmick.


A few years ago, there was a product on the play store called 8pen[0] which had a huge learning curve but was insanely useful. I was able to type while running on the treadmill, or with my phone under my desk in class. Unfortunately they took it off the play store for reasons I don't understand

[0]: http://www.8pen.com/


Yeah 8pen was the one that first got me interested in alternative input methods. It was quite cool coming from boring horrible qwerty phone keyboards. I personally couldn't quite get it down, my consistency was very low. Still, sad to hear it's not available anymore, from what I heard it worked quite well for some.


I switched entirely over to MessagEase a few months ago. Getting deterministic results from typing still feels refreshing, even now.

I'll second the recommendation.


Same, even if I can type blindfolded on my laptop. But the regular users do fine. Which let me think it's optimized for limited message delivery in size and vocabulary.

Indeed, I noticed that if I disable auto-correct then keep using very simple words, and short messages, I have much less problems.

Of course, answering with emojis mean no risk of typos.


I wonder if this is the cause of many of my misspellings on my phone.

Often I'm trying to type in names of wines, domaines, vineyards, etc. - the CellarTracker app is probably the destination of the majority of my keystrokes. I could swear sometimes that the wrong character got entered even though I was pretty sure I hit the right key.

And of course now I'll be hypersensitive to this possibility, and cherry-pick evidence to confirm my suspicions.


Do you have a source for that? I'm quite interested in reading about it.


Apple version[0], Microsoft's take [1], related research by Google [2]. My Google keywords were 'smartphone keyboard dynamic touch targets' btw.

[0] https://www.cnet.com/news/iphone-keyboard-learns-what-you-ty...

[1] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/wp-content/uploads/...

[2] https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.c...


Swiftkey has a "tap map" screen[0] that shows the adjustments it's made.

[0]: https://i.imgur.com/q42xiqg.jpg


It was in a video about the early development of the iphone IIRC, they were discussing how much detail went into the keyboard. I don't have the url in mind right now sorry.


I believe the first version of the iPhone OS did this. It was terrible (often it was literally impossible to type the thing you wanted) and they quickly replaced it with autocorrect instead.


hm interesting, from memory it was a bit of glorifying the history of the iphone and its innovation, so maybe they hid how user felt. But to me it felt like real great work...


phew.. I think that someone might have been me, if you're talking about qwerted? https://vimeo.com/8716996


Pretty much, yes ;)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: